Tuesday, December 29, 2020

Price Transmission, Economic Policy and the Three Farm Laws...

The govt may tweak income tax rate to increase demand of the salaried class and the middle class as it has been pending since a long back at par with the indirect taxes and the corporate tax cut rationalisations of the tax structure... Corporate are not passing cost gain and lower prices to the consumers.. Banks and the govt (oil prices), too... 


Though, inflation and lower debt may increase demand, but disinflation may increase the value of money, too, and demand... Both, low prices and higher price expectations increase demand and spending, but high prices and lower price expectations may delay demand and spending and growth and expectations, increasing money supply would further increase demand by increasing the real incomes and returns on money... 


Higher income, after tax, may increase demand and spending by the consumers while investors would increase investment in the sight of higher demand which would increase price expectations and spending and growth... When both demand and supply would increase prices and lower unemployment and would increase growth upto full employment...


Refinancing and restructuring of the NPAs due to interest cost and recession could help the investors... Refinancing at current rates (floating rates) could save a few of the bad debt due to low demand and higher cost... The RBI might control business by providing forward guidance about prices using the interest rate mechanism... 


The inflation target band is more important than the average target, prices move between highs and lows and also due to change in price expectations... High prices and expectations signal high demand and higher interest rate and lower supply and further higher prices and vice versa based on the monetary policy actions... 


If prices remain stable in the band it means expectations are stable between 2-6%... Below 2% its a case of cut and above 6% means its a case for hike, though the RBI has tolerated higher inflation during covid... The investors could take advantage of the monetary policy forward guidance to take investment decisions since inflation and inflation expectations and interest rate and expectations are stable... The inflation has barely crossed the upper and lower limit since the inflation targeting has been adopted...


Hike could signal hold on investment and increase supply and cut to signal demand and expansion... lower prices mean more demand and higher price expectations and higher prices mean more supply and lower price expectations... Lower prices mean it’s time to demand and invest more which would also stabilise the prices and higher prices mean it time to increase supply... Business expectations reinforce prices... 


The stock markets market-cap to GDP ratio is still low compared to the recovery (in the stocks) seen after the 2008 recession stimulus... The stock prices might be expensive, but not from the time perspective... The stock market might be at all time high, but stock prices have been in the correction mode at many occasions since 2013... 


Though the stock market is reaching late at 47, 000 which might be achieved earlier without heavy corrections... The stock markets still have much space (potential) to go up... The markets may try to catch up pace to level the loss in the midcap and small caps stock prices since 2017... Large caps still could be safe heavens... they have just recovered from the March 2020 correct and could scale new heights...


Strong rupee expectations could increase foreign capital inflows resulting in further lower interest rate and lower dollar which means more demand and investment... and, lower inflation and higher real wages... which also means higher productivity and competitiveness...


INDIA's debt market is largely underdeveloped since it lacks proper corporate bonds market so the foreign investment could flow in as a result of easing abroad like the US economy... When foreign money would pour in it would lower the interest rate and increase bond prices which would be a gain... The interest rate in the emerging markets would converge to the developed countries zero real interest rate... 


In the developed world higher money supply has resulted in lower borrowing cost and prices and higher supply which has lowered prices or inflation... Bonds do well during lowdown when the interest rate are lower due to higher money supply and higher bond prices which have a negative relationship with inflation and prices in the broader economy...


The three farm laws are scrapped in the hindsight to increase farmers' bargaining power when there are more avenues to sell the produce, more players in the market with competitive rates, even exports... APMC has been replaced to cut the cost of the middle man and mandi's are not equipped to reduce wastage and storage cost which ultimately affect inflation which profit mandis and not the farmers... 


Even more the concept of MSP is flawed, the govt sets MSP and buys it own, what a market it is where buyers set the prices and not utility and demand/supply? What is this arrangement? Prices must be set by the farmers according to the cost... The cost for Punjab and Haryana farmers is low due to too much subsidy for water guzzling crops, though, farmers at the other locations, having less than two acres need Maximum Prices, why they would sell at minimum prices...? 


The farmers must consult poor farmers at other locations, before demanding removal of farm laws... they must win their support that they would sell at min prices or max prices... Contract farming would further increase demand and prices and investment in crops in demand...


We need more investment in the aggregation of the farm sector... We actually need an aggregator of aggregators....


Some question…Why the govt is forcing the farmers in to uncharted waters when nobody knows about market or frankly speaking in the stock market of grains... all could lose... Nobody can know the markets...A stock market is a risky place to be with without the regulation…


Modi lost several rural seats even in Gujarat also alongwith many states though he dedicated few past budgets to rural and agri sector to gain the lost ground when the Congress has good hold in rural areas due to MGNREGS... He is trying to appease rural areas by allocating higher funds for the rural guarantee scheme playing the old vote bank politics...


 Modi's actions are timid and half hearted to move to a market system while his government is reiterating that mandis and msp would continue... The govt is trying to stop the farmers stir somehow... but farmers are unwilling to go back in case of unclear govt intentions... In a market system the farmers could still be losers because they lack knowledge of economics and business and big players could still play spoilsport at the cost of small and marginal farmers... 


Poor farmers would lose and would be pushed to sell low in absence of any price forecasting models... Rich would have both money and grain to withstand low prices, but not small farmers..... This year too a lot of funds would go a longway to satisfy the peasants and farms, an unproductive sector like a black hole, no amount of money can satisfy poor and small farmers who actually need education and skills to grow and develop...


What people expect and how do they behave could turn it into a reality, if people have money and they expect higher price expectations they would increase demand and hold supply that would further feed into the the price channel or increase prices, but if they expect lower price expectations they would hold demand and spending which would also increase supply that would again lower prices... 

Wednesday, December 16, 2020

Farmers' Discontent and Monetary Policy and Models to Follow...

Farmers need maximum support prices... They would gain when people would compete to buy the produce, they would bid the produce prices high, otherwise the govt would buy at MSP... The govt has not bought enough through the Mandi's due to record production in the past few years and lower price expectations...


Why govt shall buy? It has no money... it only plays a middle man role increasing the cost of supply...


Oversupply of labor has reduced the share per labour in agriculture... we need skills to provide jobs to excess labor and use technology to increase productivity and wage per person... middle man chain has further depressed wages... Rural population is too much dependent on agriculture for occupation...


RBI rate cut end points that the rate cut cycle has almost bottomed out, this is the lowest since 2013 and the RBI has underscored an accommodative stand even when inflation is supply side driven, therefore rate cut is not in sight for atleast a quarter and rate cut only when the inflation pips low... 


Materially there would be only a minor difference, high inflation means higher nominal interest rate and lower inflation means lower nominal interest rate, when both mean a stable real interest rate, but changes in nominal interest rate reinforce inflation/disinflation/deflation. 


Lower inflation means lower interest rate and more supply and demand due to lower prices, only if there is unemployment in the economy, full employment would constrain demand and supply and higher inflation means higher interest rate and lower supply and demand and higher prices and higher unemployment... 


Low and stable prices and interest rate or real interest rate and full employment would help achieve the potential growth rate... Lower prices mean higher supply and demand and higher prices mean lower supply and demand...


The RBI may abandon the inflation target since it (inflation) is supply side driven, higher prices could increase supply and contain prices through the market... Demand is low and accommodative monetary policy could increase demand and price expectations and spending... The RBI has already tolerated higher inflation during covid induced recession... Higher inflation expectations are good for spending...


Maintaining inflation expectations is important for spending decisions, both consumption and investment... Higher price expectations from a low base seem a rational one... Higher prices also mean higher demand and supply...


We have two models to choose from US and China... US' strong currency model or internal devaluation model which means cheaper imports and higher competitiveness and exports and China's cheap currency model or external devaluation model which means cheaper currency and cheaper exports or expensive imports... We gain from both... Though, Chinese model restrict some imports/domestic demand, the US models increases domestic demand...


Economic growth around...

  Food and fuel inflation is high in INDIA... the main sources of inflation... Lower fuel taxes could help lower inflation and increase prod...